CartThrob Subscriptions, 3d secure (stripe)
CartThrob
4 weeks ago
This seems to be a more common occurrence for international orders (relative to US).
I suspect that when Stripe flags an order as requiring 3D Secure verification, CartThrob/Subscriptions doesn't know how to handle it.
Currently these subscriptions come back as successful (from a CT perspective) even though they have no transaction ID as would be expected from a valid order.
Error has these elements:
```
File: system/user/addons/cartthrob/cartthrob/plugins/payment_gateways/Cartthrob_stripe.php
Line: 241
The following error occurred:
E_WARNING: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, null given
```
And then:
```
Line: 296
<html>
<head>
<meta charset="UTF-8" />
<meta http-equiv="refresh" content="0;url='https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct_0u6hxDREDACTEDZy2XUfGxu&payment_intent=pi_REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED'" />
<title>Redirecting to https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct__REDACTED&payment_intent=pi__REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED</title>;
</head>
<body>
Redirecting to https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct__REDACTED&payment_intent=pi__REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED.
</body>
```
And then:
```
TypeError caught:
Cartthrob_stripe::chargeToken(): Return value must be of type CartThrob\Transactions\TransactionState, null returned
user/addons/cartthrob/cartthrob/plugins/payment_gateways/Cartthrob_stripe.php:476
#0 user/addons/cartthrob/libraries/Cartthrob_payments.php(303): Cartthrob_stripe->chargeToken('card_0MpZc7xDzM...', 'cus_Lzzr4tS4o2l...', false)
#1 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/OrdersService.php(191): Cartthrob_payments->chargeToken('card_0MpZc7xDzM...', 'cus_Lzzr4tS4o2l...', false)
#2 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/BillingService.php(67): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\OrdersService->chargeSubscription(Object(CartThrob\Subscriptions\Models\Subscription), Array)
#3 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/BillingService.php(119): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\BillingService->processSubscription(Object(CartThrob\Subscriptions\Models\Subscription))
#4 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Commands/Rebill.php(57): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\BillingService->processRebill()
#5 ee/ExpressionEngine/Cli/Cli.php(273): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Commands\Rebill->handle()
#6 ee/ExpressionEngine/Core/Core.php(144): ExpressionEngine\Cli\Cli->process()
#7 ee/ExpressionEngine/Core/Core.php(116): ExpressionEngine\Core\Core->bootCli()
#8 ee/ExpressionEngine/Boot/boot.php(184): ExpressionEngine\Core\Core->run(Object(ExpressionEngine\Core\Request))
#9 ee/eecli.php(105): require_once('...')
#10 {main}
```
A bit more detail is in a Github issue: https://github.com/CartThrob/support/issues/15
I suspect that when Stripe flags an order as requiring 3D Secure verification, CartThrob/Subscriptions doesn't know how to handle it.
Currently these subscriptions come back as successful (from a CT perspective) even though they have no transaction ID as would be expected from a valid order.
Error has these elements:
```
File: system/user/addons/cartthrob/cartthrob/plugins/payment_gateways/Cartthrob_stripe.php
Line: 241
The following error occurred:
E_WARNING: foreach() argument must be of type array|object, null given
```
And then:
```
Line: 296
<html>
<head>
<meta charset="UTF-8" />
<meta http-equiv="refresh" content="0;url='https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct_0u6hxDREDACTEDZy2XUfGxu&payment_intent=pi_REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED'" />
<title>Redirecting to https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct__REDACTED&payment_intent=pi__REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED</title>;
</head>
<body>
Redirecting to https://hooks.stripe.com/3d_secure_2/hosted?merchant=acct__REDACTED&payment_intent=pi__REDACTED&payment_intent_client_secret=pi__REDACTED_secret__REDACTED&publishable_key=pk_live__REDACTED&source=payatt__REDACTED.
</body>
```
And then:
```
TypeError caught:
Cartthrob_stripe::chargeToken(): Return value must be of type CartThrob\Transactions\TransactionState, null returned
user/addons/cartthrob/cartthrob/plugins/payment_gateways/Cartthrob_stripe.php:476
#0 user/addons/cartthrob/libraries/Cartthrob_payments.php(303): Cartthrob_stripe->chargeToken('card_0MpZc7xDzM...', 'cus_Lzzr4tS4o2l...', false)
#1 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/OrdersService.php(191): Cartthrob_payments->chargeToken('card_0MpZc7xDzM...', 'cus_Lzzr4tS4o2l...', false)
#2 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/BillingService.php(67): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\OrdersService->chargeSubscription(Object(CartThrob\Subscriptions\Models\Subscription), Array)
#3 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Services/BillingService.php(119): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\BillingService->processSubscription(Object(CartThrob\Subscriptions\Models\Subscription))
#4 user/addons/cartthrob_subscriptions/src/Commands/Rebill.php(57): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Services\BillingService->processRebill()
#5 ee/ExpressionEngine/Cli/Cli.php(273): CartThrob\Subscriptions\Commands\Rebill->handle()
#6 ee/ExpressionEngine/Core/Core.php(144): ExpressionEngine\Cli\Cli->process()
#7 ee/ExpressionEngine/Core/Core.php(116): ExpressionEngine\Core\Core->bootCli()
#8 ee/ExpressionEngine/Boot/boot.php(184): ExpressionEngine\Core\Core->run(Object(ExpressionEngine\Core\Request))
#9 ee/eecli.php(105): require_once('...')
#10 {main}
```
A bit more detail is in a Github issue: https://github.com/CartThrob/support/issues/15
about 2 weeks ago
For those finding this. Patch for this is in testing by creativearc currently!
Cheers,
-Tom Jaeger
Cheers,
-Tom Jaeger