We use cookies to improve your experience. No personal information is gathered and we don't serve ads. Cookies Policy.

ExpressionEngine Logo ExpressionEngine
Features Pricing Support Find A Developer
Partners Upgrades
Blog Add-Ons Learn
Docs Forums University
Log In or Sign Up
Log In Sign Up
ExpressionEngine Logo
Features Pro new Support Find A Developer
Partners Upgrades
Blog Add-Ons Learn
Docs Forums University Blog
  • Home
  • Forums

Fields still limited to one channel, but creation process has more steps

Developer Preview

Derek Hogue's avatar
Derek Hogue
317 posts
10 years ago
Derek Hogue's avatar Derek Hogue

Love all the progress I’m seeing so far, especially with the recent style updates in DP4.

I got my hopes up momentarily when I went to create a new field group and saw that there was a list of fields I could pick from when creating or editing it. Momentarily I hoped that this new interface meant that I could in fact assign the same field to multiple field groups.

Alas, once a field is assigned in one field group, it’s still unavailable to select for others. So, this behaviour is unchanged.

But whereas previously I would create a field group and then immediately start adding fields which would automatically be assigned to that field group, I now need to reverse my process and first create all of my fields, and then go back and create my field group and assign all those fields to it. Then later, if I need to add more fields, I need do the same thing again, all involving several steps and interface navigation.

This to me is more clicks for no gain. The process makes sense if field which can live inside multiple field groups, but not if things are status quo.

       
James Mathias's avatar
James Mathias
225 posts
10 years ago
James Mathias's avatar James Mathias

Hi Derek,

Thanks for the feedback, I recognized this in DP3, and updated the UI, but the changes didn’t make it into DP4.

An issue has be filed to make it work more like it did before in 2.x.

I original designed the UI for having custom fields independent of groups, and being able to be put into multiple groups or tied directly to a channel, however the underlying functionality isn’t going to be in 3, so I pulled the UI back.

       
iainsaxon's avatar
iainsaxon
3 posts
10 years ago
iainsaxon's avatar iainsaxon
An issue has be filed to make it work more like it did before in 2.x.

That’s a shame as I was looking forward to the prospect of sharing custom fields across groups. Helps reduce the number of custom fields to maintain and having 6 descriptions fields that essentially do the same thing has always seemed a bit messy in EE.

       
James Mathias's avatar
James Mathias
225 posts
10 years ago
James Mathias's avatar James Mathias

Agreed, and the concept is on our vision map, it’s just not going to make it into 3.0.

       
iainsaxon's avatar
iainsaxon
3 posts
10 years ago
iainsaxon's avatar iainsaxon

Good to hear its still on the roadmap.

I started porting an addon to use a field instead of publish tabs as soon as I saw the prospect of shared fields but it looks like I’ll have to stick with tabs for now.

Thanks for the heads-up.

       

Reply

Sign In To Reply

ExpressionEngine Home Features Pro Contact Version Support
Learn Docs University Forums
Resources Support Add-Ons Partners Blog
Privacy Terms Trademark Use License

Packet Tide owns and develops ExpressionEngine. © Packet Tide, All Rights Reserved.