Mark I couldn’t disagree with you more. I use Illustrator on my 13” just fine, thank you. The right size notebook is the one you’ll use and take on the go. Are you more productive with larger screen real estate? Uncontested. Are you productive if your notebook stays on your desk when you’re out? That translates to, oh, zero Productivity Units. I refuse to heft around 17” “portables”.
Derek please don’t take what I said previously as an insult. It was not meant like that at all. This is definitely one of those things which is different for different people.
Myself I used to work on a 12” monitor back in the day but just couldn’t possibly do that nowadays due to the work that I do and the way that I do that work. I not only do web-development and design for the internet but also page layout for magazine work using InDesign and myself couldn’t possibly use anything less than 17” to get everything done or I would be all over the place with palettes and zoom levels etc… 😉
For me the 17” is the right size notebook and definitely the one I have taken on the go everywhere. I have done photo-shoots all over the world in some of the most inhospitable conditions known to mankind and I have to say that my Mac saved the day every time. Saying that though if I even just had the smallest available Mac item known to mankind then that would have given me comfort too as I just love anything Mac related 😊
Am I more productive with more screen real-estate? I would have to say a definite yes to that as I work in everything from 3D applications and page layout to photography apps so for me this is a definite yes. Luckily I am one of the people who is happy to use the Tab command in Photoshop to hide the palettes as I know a lot of people who like to have a second monitor just for their palettes!! Aggghhh!!! Looking all the way to one side to find a brush or something else when you can just press tab, they must have money to burn!! 😉
As you say though this is definitely different for different people and totally depends a lot I guess on exactly what it is you are doing on your computer so I totally agree with you there. Myself though for development of a web-site I still like to work with my graphics at a really nice resolution and then size down afterwards and prefer to get more of the picture without zooming out and missing minute parts of the detail. Admittedly it’s not that much that goes missing but I just prefer a slightly bigger work area wherever I can.
Anyway hopefully you didn’t take what I said as an insult as it was far from that.
Best wishes,
Mark