+1 for jeromecoupe’s feature requests (couldn’t have summarized it better, I demoed EE2.1.4 and this is exactly what site owners need)
Of all the presentations I did, I never got a question from customers to create or manage file uploads in subdirectories. But batch uploading and large file uploading almost always came up.
I think it certainly depends on the market segment you’re working in - my clients generally do news sites, large ones at that. Its all well and good to say “clients only ruin things”, but ultimately it’s the client’s site and you can only give them a good start. Some clients needto be managed and something of a safety net, and others are savvy enough to be let free to do their own thing. Often your work takes on a new life; giving them the flexibility to explore options is important, and with any luck they’ll call you back to do “enhancements”, not “fixes”...
Basically it’s not enough have to choose between one solution or another - it’d be great to have both default folder for some groups and an open system for high-level groups. We need both.
I’ve worked for the two largest news organizations in the Netherlands, and the primitive native file manager made them question the power and flexibility of the platform. “If they can’t get this right, what else is lurking inside?” is the generalized response..completely unfair, but I also can’t say I don’t get what they mean…this should be core functionality, not a plug-in that can break later. They’re time-sensitive and change-phobic, but not stupid.