Hi Robin - no, unfortunately they do not work as expected.
New Topics Search
————————-
If I look at the forum index I can see the folder-icons in a more distinct color indicating that new messages have been written in a certain forum since my last visit. Yet, when I click the New Topics Seach link I get an empty list or a list which does not contain all the new messages written since my last visit.
Active Topics Search
——————————
This will not display the posts updated in the last 12 hours.
When I tested it just now I got 1 result in “New Topics Search” and 0 in Active Topics Search (I would expect 4 in new topics since 4 topics have been updated, and more in Active topics search).
I understand from the message you linked to that there is some confusion between topics and posts. The one result returned was an old topic, but which had new posts in it.
That’s the behaviour I expect (all topics which has been updated since last visit).
But if that is not the intended behaviour - if the behaviour is supposed to be entirely new topics created since last visit - then there is still something weird going on (since I was returned the old topic with a new post in it).
Just as a sidenote - I think the standard (and expected) behaviour for this kind of feature in a forum is “New posts” since last visit (e.g. it will show a list of all topics which have been updated since last visit). This goes for the software I’ve used earlier at least (InvisionBoard, phpBB and SMF).
- bjorn